Read-alikes

Books Like Shiver, Little Toy

If you loved Shiver, Little Toy by Holly Ryan, these 12 books share its tropes (bully, forbidden romance, morally grey MC, possessive-obsessive MC) and sit at a similar heat and darkness (it rates 4/5 for spice and 4/5 for darkness). Each pick says what it has in common, so you can choose before you buy.

Shiver, Little Toy: spice level, darkness and content warnings →

1. 

   1. Twisted Heathens: A Dark Reverse Harem Romance (Blackwood Institute, Book 1)

   J Rose

   Shares bully, revenge, forbidden romance; also Why Choose / Reverse Harem (Dark); spice 4/5, darkness 4/5.

   Check Price →
2. 

   2. Ruin Me: Crestmont University, Book 1

   Eve Newton

   Shares bully, revenge, morally grey MC; also Why Choose / Reverse Harem (Dark); spice 4/5, darkness 4/5.

   Check Price →
3. 

   3. The Wicked Games We Play: A Dark Reverse Harem Romance

   W. A. Marlow

   Shares bully, revenge, morally grey MC; also Why Choose / Reverse Harem (Dark); spice 4/5, darkness 4/5.

   Check Price →
4. 

   4. They Break Beauty: Vicious Things, Book 1

   Leia King

   Shares bully, revenge, morally grey MC; also Why Choose / Reverse Harem (Dark); spice 4/5, darkness 5/5.

   Check Price →
5. 

   5. Ill Will: A Reverse Harem Bully Romance (Bonds of Blood Book 1)

   Cate Corvin

   Shares bully, revenge, possessive-obsessive MC; also Why Choose / Reverse Harem (Dark); spice 4/5, darkness 4/5.

   Check Price →
6. 

   6. Dirty Deeds: A Reverse Harem Bully Romance (Bonds of Blood Book 3)

   Cate Corvin

   Shares bully, revenge, possessive-obsessive MC; also Why Choose / Reverse Harem (Dark); spice 4/5, darkness 4/5.

   Check Price →
7. 

   7. King of Envy

   Ana Huang

   Shares revenge, forbidden romance, morally grey MC; also Why Choose / Reverse Harem (Dark); spice 4/5, darkness 4/5.

   Check Price →
8. 

   8. Break Me: A Dark Reverse Harem Romance

   A. L.

   Shares bully, revenge, morally grey MC; also Why Choose / Reverse Harem (Dark); spice 4/5, darkness 5/5.

   Check Price →
9. 

   9. Redeemed: A Dark Reverse Harem Bully Romance

   E. Bishop

   Shares bully, revenge, morally grey MC; also Why Choose / Reverse Harem (Dark); spice 4/5, darkness 5/5.

   Check Price →
10. 

    10. Savage Court of Submission: A Dark, Bullly romantasy (Filthy Elite Book 1)

    Ava Mason

    Shares bully, forbidden romance, morally grey MC; also Why Choose / Reverse Harem (Dark); spice 4/5, darkness 4/5.

    Check Price →
11. 

    11. Crash: Bleeding Hearts, Book 1: A Dark Secret Society Reverse Harem

    Eve Newton

    Shares bully, forbidden romance, morally grey MC; also Why Choose / Reverse Harem (Dark); spice 4/5, darkness 4/5.

    Check Price →
12. 

    12. Thief: A Dark Reverse Harem Romance (Sterling Falls, Book 1)

    S. Massery

    Shares bully, forbidden romance, morally grey MC; also Why Choose / Reverse Harem (Dark); spice 4/5, darkness 4/5.

    Check Price →

Matches are calculated from Readark’s own tags: shared tropes (rarer ones count more), subgenre, and how close the spice and darkness ratings are. Books from the same series are left out — see the reading order instead. How we rate