Read-alikes
Books Like Butcher & Blackbird
If you loved Butcher & Blackbird by Brynne Weaver, these 12 books share its tropes (antihero / villain MC, morally grey MC) and sit at a similar heat and darkness (it rates 4/5 for spice and 4/5 for darkness). Each pick says what it has in common, so you can choose before you buy.
Butcher & Blackbird: spice level, darkness and content warnings →
1. Phantasma: A dark fantasy romance (Wicked Games Book 1)
Shares antihero / villain MC, morally grey MC; spice 4/5, darkness 4/5.
Check Price →
2. The Sweetest Fiend (Deluxe Limited Edition): A Novel – A Dark Romantasy of Fae Magic and Captive Romance Inspired by the Pied Piper (Played by the Piper, 1)
Shares antihero / villain MC, morally grey MC; spice 4/5, darkness 4/5.
Check Price →
4. Lights Out: An Into Darkness Novel
Shares antihero / villain MC, morally grey MC; spice 4/5, darkness 5/5.
Check Price →
6. One Dark Window
Shares antihero / villain MC, morally grey MC; spice 3/5, darkness 4/5.
Check Price →
7. Queen of Rot and Pain: A Dark Fantasy Romance (The Pale Court Book 2)
Shares antihero / villain MC, morally grey MC; spice 3/5, darkness 4/5.
Check Price →
9. Bad Bishop: A Dark Mafia Romance (Society of Villains Book 1)
Shares antihero / villain MC, morally grey MC; spice 4/5, darkness 5/5.
Check Price →
10. God of Fury: Legacy of Gods, Book 5
Shares antihero / villain MC, morally grey MC; spice 5/5, darkness 4/5.
Check Price →
11. The Death Club (Dead Men Walking Duet Book 1)
Shares antihero / villain MC, morally grey MC; spice 4/5, darkness 4/5.
Check Price →
12. Sweetly Unhinged: A Dark Rom-Com (Devoted in Darkness, Book 1)
Shares antihero / villain MC, morally grey MC; spice 4/5, darkness 4/5.
Check Price →
Matches are calculated from Readark’s own tags: shared tropes (rarer ones count more), subgenre, and how close the spice and darkness ratings are. Books from the same series are left out — see the reading order instead. How we rate